Sunday, February 24, 2008

Myth of Renters Tax Payments....and rebates

I did a little bit of research today regarding where this state and other came up with the concept that renters that don't actually pay taxes are due rebates for said taxes they didn't pay. Apparently, the research is only political and generally is estimates between 17-19 percent of a renters monthly payment. As a former property owner who apparently was a part of this process I am going to have to call foul.

I don't know who comes up with these numbers but I am sure they are completely delusional. Rental income is almost completely derived based on market demand and competitive pricing. To try to claim that taxes are a part is as much fiction as claiming that the consume product index plays a part. People who rent properties look at other who do the same and set their price accordingly. Even if it doesn't cover the cost, many renters factor in capital appreciation and other quality of life issues that play a part (deductions, investment etc).

The net is that the claim that any renter anywhere is depending on the rentee to pay 20 percent of the their rent bill is a complete fabrication. But of course, this is completely un-pc in this state so we don't want to disabuse our poor rental clients of the belief that they actually pay property taxes.

Here is the rub. If you make 20k per year, you don't pay property taxes unless you own the place you live. So any rebate you get is not a rebate. It is state assistance. If only our politicians were not in the vig business, they would be honest and let the taxpayer know that these rebates are actually welfare with the express purpose of buying votes of irresponsible politicians. Pure and simlpe. If you knew that, would you support it?

1 Comments:

At June 15, 2008 at 6:30 PM , Anonymous Anonymous said...

You are very lucky that you are in a position to comment at all. I deal with renters all the time. If you actually believe that renters don't help pay property tax then you are the delusional one. I have yet to meet one renter who, for no fault of their own, lives at a standard substantially lower than that of the landlord. I know of no landlords who actually use the rental income to improve, or even maintain the places they rent. Most renters live in poor,if not deplorable, conditions. It is well known that other houeowners who do not rent detest living in neighborhoods where people do rent. The number one reason: landlords don't keep up the places they rent anywhere near the standard they would if they had to live there. I can gaurantee that they home you live in and the place you rent are drastically different. Why don't you switch and live in the rental for a few months and see if you still sit on your high horse.What would be really fair would be to give more than the 18% to the renters who really deserve it. They should give a 100% if the renter uses it to repair, improve or maintain the property. Obviously the landlord never will. Remember what goes around comes around. One day you will be in some situation comparable to your tenant. Maybe not a rental/landlord issue, but something where you are dependant on a greedy selfish person. I hope you remember how you treated your tenant when it comes back to you.

 

Post a Comment

Subscribe to Post Comments [Atom]

<< Home